Skip to main content

Science Magazine Had My Mass Reviewed, Together With It’S Glorious, Glorious.

Science Magazine had my majority “Lost inward Math” reviewed past times Dr. Djuna Lize Croon, a postdoctoral associate at the Department of Physics at Dartmouth College, inward New Hampshire, USA. Dr. Croon has worked on the really query topics that my majority exposes equally mathematical fantasies, such equally “extra natural inflation” or “holographic composite Higgs models,” thus choosing her to review my majority is an interesting motion for sure.

Dr. Croon does non disappoint. After just having read a whole majority that explains how scientists neglect to admit that their opinions are influenced past times the communities they are business office of, Dr. Croon begins her review past times quoting an anonymous Facebook friend who denigrates me equally a blogger as well as tells Dr. Croon to dislike my majority because I am non “offering solutions.” In her review, then, Dr. Croon reports beingness shocked to detect that I disagree amongst her scientific heroes, dislikes that I set frontwards ain opinions, as well as and thus promptly arrives at the same determination that her Facebook friend kindly offered beforehand.

The electrical load that I just criticize my community without making recommendations for improvement is specially interesting because to laid out amongst it’s wrong. I produce while out really clearly inward the majority that I yell back theoretical physicists inward the foundations should focus on mathematical consistency as well as making contact to experiment rather than blathering most beauty. I also state concretely what topics I yell back are most promising, though I warn the reader that of course of educational activity I equally good am biased as well as they should come upwards to their ain conclusions.

Even leaving aside that I produce offering recommendations for improvement, I don’t know why it’s my labor to come upwards up amongst something else for those people to do. If they can’t come upwards up amongst something else themselves, peradventure nosotros should just halt throwing coin at them?

On a to a greater extent than technical note, I detect it depressing that Dr. Croon inward her review writes that naturalness has “a statistical meaning” fifty-fifty though I explicate similar a dozen times throughout the majority that y'all can’t utter of probabilities without having a probability distribution. We convey alone this railroad train of laws of nature. We convey no statistics from which nosotros could infer a likelihood of getting just these laws.

In summary, this review does an awesome labor highlighting the really problems that my majority is about.

Update June 17th: Remarkably enough, the editors at Science decided to take the facebook quote from the review.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Outraged Nigh The Google Multifariousness Memo? One Desire You Lot To Mean Value Nigh It.

Chairs. [ Image: Verco ] That leaked internal memo from James Damore at Google ? The 1 that says 1 shouldn’t hold off employees inwards all professions to reverberate the demographics of the whole population? Well, that was a pretty dumb affair to write. But non because it’s wrong. Dumb is that Damore thought he could receive got a reasoned give-and-take close this. In the USA, out of all places. The version of Damore’s memo that get-go appeared on Gizmodo missed references together with images. But meanwhile, the multifariousness memo has its ain website together with it comes with links together with graphics. Damore’s strikes me equally a pamphlet produced past times a well-meaning, but also utterly clueless, immature white man. He didn’t deserve to get fired for this. He deserved mayhap a slap on the too-quickly typing fingers. But inwards his world, bespeak for give-and-take is evidently plenty to learn fired. I don’t commonly write close the underrepresentation of wo...
Post a Comment
Read more

Dear Dr B: Should 1 Report String Theory?

Strings. [image: freeimages.com ] “Greetings doctor Hossenfelder! I am a Princeton physics major who regularly reads your wonderful blog. I lately came across a curious passage inwards Brian Greene’s introduction to a reprint edition of Einstein's Meaning of Relativity which claims that: “Superstring theory successfully merges full general relativity in addition to quantum mechanics [...] Moreover, non exclusively does superstring theory merge full general relativity with quantum mechanics, but it also has the capacity to comprehend — on an equal reason — the electromagnetic force, the weak force, in addition to the strong force. Within superstring theory, each of these forces is merely associated with a dissimilar vibrational designing of a string. And so, similar a guitar chord composed of 4 dissimilar notes, the 4 forces of nature are united inside the music of superstring theory. What’s more, the same goes for all of thing every bit well. The electron, the quarks,...
Post a Comment
Read more

Particle Physics Right Away Belly Up

Particle physics. Artist’s impression. Professor Ben Allanach is a particle physicist at Cambridge University. He exactly wrote an promotion for my book that appeared on Aeon roughly days agone nether the championship “Going Nowhere Fast” . I’m kidding of course, Allanach’s essay has no relation to my book. At to the lowest degree non that I know of. But it’s non a coincidence he writes virtually the really problems that I also speak over inward my book . After all, the whole argue I wrote the mass was that this province of affairs was foreseeable: The Large Hadron Collider hasn’t institute prove for whatever novel particles likewise the Higgs-boson (at to the lowest degree non thence far), thence at i time particle physicists are at a loss for how to proceed. Even if they uncovering something inward the information that’s nonetheless to come, it is clear already that their predictions were wrong. Theory-development inward particle physics for the terminal forty years has work...
Post a Comment
Read more